Back to the archiveChildhood / 1940s–1980s

The Penny Sweets Counter: Choosing from the Jars

A small purchase that made every choice feel large

Illustration for The Penny Sweets Counter: Choosing from the Jars
Illustration created for WistMem; not an archival photograph.
By WistMem EditorialPublished April 24, 2026Updated September 29, 20262 min read9 readers

Make this page easier to read

Your choices are saved on this device.

Text size

The penny sweets counter asked children to choose, count, and wait while a shopkeeper filled a paper bag. Museum objects and shop histories show how much of that memory belonged to the counter itself.

A few coins could make the walk to a sweet shop feel like a serious errand. The glass jars looked close enough to touch, but the counter and the shopkeeper stood between the child and the final choice. One sweet might leave enough money for another; choosing too quickly could mean regretting it all the way home.

What happened across the counter?

The shopkeeper counted or weighed, reached for a scoop, and tipped the selection into a paper bag. The ritual depended on trust: the child watched closely, the adult knew the prices, and the coins had to cover the decision. A Smithsonian candy tin from United Retail Candy Stores is a reminder that packaging itself helped sell a treat, while its catalog notes the appeal of smaller candy shops even when larger chains offered inexpensive sweets. Across the Atlantic, Historic England lists the Village Sweet Shop in Ruislip and describes its late nineteenth-century shopfront. The American candy store and British sweet shop were not identical, but both made the display part of the invitation.

Illustration for The Penny Sweets Counter: Choosing from the JarsIllustration created for WistMem; not an archival photograph.

Why did choosing take so long?

The jar held more than one serving, so a child was assembling a mixture rather than selecting a sealed product. Color, shape, flavor, and the number that would fit the budget all mattered. A friend might recommend one item and warn against another. The queue behind them added pressure. Even a familiar shop could change when a favorite jar was empty or a new sweet appeared near the till. Those details made the same small purchase feel different every week.

Illustration for The Penny Sweets Counter: Choosing from the JarsIllustration created for WistMem; not an archival photograph.

The memory inside a paper bag

If a family recalls a particular counter, ask what the bag looked like and whether the shopkeeper knew the child by name. The coin value may be hard to reconstruct across decades of changing prices; the act of deciding is easier to remember. Sometimes the sweetest part was carrying the bag unopened for a few steps, saving the first choice for the walk home. The bag was small; the choosing took the whole afternoon.

For the American counter where a drink could become a performance, visit The Corner Drugstore Soda Fountain.

From a story to a conversation

What does it bring back for you?

Ask someone who remembers, or begin with your own version. A few words can be enough.

Where did you like to spend an afternoon when you were young?

Then ask: What could keep you there longer than you planned?

Find more conversation starters Choose what feels comfortable. Ask before recording or sharing someone’s words.

Relive the Memory

Find a little of the story.

Something here bring back a memory? Take a look at what you can find today.

Searching for: vintage retro candy store penny sweets

Vintage & collectible finds

Look for older objects and collectibles connected to this memory.

Search eBay (opens in a new tab)

Related finds on Amazon

Explore items related to the same topic, from familiar styles to things made today.

Search Amazon (opens in a new tab)

These links open search results. Items, prices, and availability vary.

Affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. As an eBay Partner, WistMem may earn from qualifying purchases.

nostalgiachildhood memoriescandy storepenny sweets1960s

Does this bring back memories?

Share this story with someone who would remember.